Nov 17, 2022-2022
United States of America
Twitter San Francisco Headquarters
Share
ACTIVISTS/ACT.GROUPS/DESCRIPTION OF THE GROUP
Alan Marling
TARGET
Elon Musk, Twitter
WIDELY HELD BELIEF
Big companies and their owners should respect human rights.
CASE NARRATIVE
Issue and Opponent: After closing his $44-billion purchase of Twitter on October 28, Elon Musk has had a rocky start after taking over as the new boss. The company is being criticized due to the changes to moderation and verification methods increasing the fears and concerns about disinformation. Users are also concerned about the fact that hate speech and white supremacist conspiracy theories are allowed on Twitter, and this could drive out people of color, minorities, and women. Musk’s unfair labor practices are also a concerning issue for activists, since former employees of the firm’s human rights, accessibility experience, communications, and curation departments have shared that they were either let go or their departments were dissolved.
Dilemma Action: On November 17, 2022, messages in simple white text, flashed onto the walls of Twitter’s San Francisco headquarters, protesting against Elon Musk’s supposed free speech and unfair labor practices. Insults included “supreme parasite”, “mediocre manchild”, “worthless billionaire” and “space Karen”, according to footage posted online. The projections were the work of Alan Marling, a Bay Area projection activist. Crowds began to gather outside, and the projections started to go viral online. Marling stated that he projected other messages against Musk on October 26 and November 9 and 11, 2022. He also projected previously at Twitter against Donald Trump and started there in 2017.
Outcome: After about one hour of projecting the messages, Marling packed up his equipment and went home. Activists are encouraging advertisers to pull away from the social media platform, and many users, including celebrities, are closing their accounts to show their disagreement with Musk’s practices. Musk said in a tweet that he is suing activists for these projections. Projection activism is considered a new nonviolent, silent way to protest, that allows people to interact with it as much or as little as they wish. There is no evidence of other people joining the artist in these demonstrations.
PRIMARY STRUGGLE/GOAL
NONVIOLENT TACTICS USED
DA TACTICS USED
Banners/posters/displayed communications
Skywriting and earthwriting
Symbolic lights
CASE NARRATIVE WRITER
SUCCESS METRICS
7 / 12
(MC) Media Coverage
(MSYMP) Media coverage was sympathetic to the activists
(OR) Opponent response
(PS) Dilemma action built sympathy with the public
(PUN) Punishment favored the activists
(REFR) Dilemma action reframed the narrative of the opponent
Laugtivism
PART OF A LARGER CAMPAIGN
1 / 3
Activist group continued working together after the action
RESOURCES
Project documentation
Dilemma Actions Coding Guidebook
Case study documentation
Dilemma_Actions_Analysis_Dataset
SOURCES
Puglisi, Leonardo. 2022. Twitter, November 17. Retrieved July 22, 2023. https://twitter.com/leo_puglisi6/status/1593434149586874368?s=42&t=K44Aei8FBKXXeqkT90Zkig
https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/story/2022-11-18/elon-musk-twitter-protest-projection-activist-alan-marling. Accessed April 15, 2022.
Jones, Kelly. 2022. “Yes, anti-Elon Musk messages were projected on Twitter building in San Francisco.” KDSK, November 18. Retrieved July 22, 2023. https://www.ksdk.com/article/news/verify/technology-verify/video-showing-twitter-building-projection-with-anti-elon-musk-messages-is-real/536-3635ec48-c9b1-4176-833f-3e914162d200
Anon. N.d. “Twitter HQ trolled as Musk shuts down offices.” CNN. Retrieved July 22, 2023. https://edition.cnn.com/videos/business/2022/11/18/twitter-san-francisco-hq-trolled-messages-ldn-vpx.cnn
Burn, Joe. 2022. “‘Proof Elon an idiot’: Man Trolls Musk With Projected Messages on Twitter HQ, and He Wants Your Help.” The San Francisco Standard, November 9. Retrieved July 22, 2023. https://sfstandard.com/2022/11/09/proof-elon-an-idiot-man-trolls-musk-with-projected-messages-on-twitter-hq-and-he-wants-your-help/
Cuthbertson, Anthony. 2022. “Activists project Elon Musk insults onto deserted Twitter HQ.” Independent. Retrieved July 22, 2023. https://www.independent.co.uk/tv/news/twitter-employees-musk-insults-projection-b2228841.html
Related cases
May 1, 2000-2000
Republic of Serbia
Serbian President Slobodan Milosevic used brutal methods to establish his regime, creating a massive internal system of repression. Milosevic’s regime generated ...
/
May 28, 2002-2002
Online
The Yes Men targeted the World Trade Organization (WTO). The group labels themselves anti-globalization advocates.
Dilemma Action: In 1999, The Yes Men created a...
/
Jun 14, 2010-2010
Russia
Issue and Opposition: The KGB earned its notoriety as the Soviet Union’s secret service agency during the Cold War because of its oppressive techniques against the dis...
/
Subscribe to our newsletters to get full access to all materials on our website.

